In my travels as a consultant, I have found that even in communities with full employment, there is often an underlying belief that “our town” is not what it could be or should be.
It’s not that people aren’t working in these places. For the most part, they are. It’s just that they are not working in the kind of jobs that they want. Too often, the type of jobs that are readily available do not meet the expectations of young people seeking careers, politicians and economic developers.
Young people will often move as a result, and the politicians, a largely delusional class of limited intelligence, will beg, cajole, threaten, and bully economic developers to devise plans to create higher-paying jobs, on the belief that, quoting Mark Twain, “the lack of money is the root of all evil.”
A Well-Meaning Bunch
These plans, some of which are occasionally rooted in reality, form the working basis for the profession of economic development. Practitioners are generally a likable, well-meaning bunch charged with building wealth and improving quality of life in their respective communities.
Now I know that may sound crazy, but it is true. Indeed, I once was one.
If economic developers were to adopt a motto for what they do, I would advise they consider another astute observation by Samuel Clemens, whose pen name was Mark Twain: “All good things arrive unto them that wait – and don’t die in the meantime.”
From One Bandwagon to Another
About 10 or 15 years ago, the biotech bandwagon was the thing to jump on. Just about every economic developer and his or her brother proffered the notion that their communities were more than suitable for the manipulation of genetic material without killing us all.
It finally dawned on most that biotech companies are born and thrive in only certain type of communities, typically found where there are research universities and research dollars available to create some things you really don’t want to know much about.
Today, there is an understandable excitement about the digital transformation of manufacturing, which is our next industrial revolution. Optimists that they are, many if not most economic developers believe their respective communities are well-equipped for it.
After all, they have the consultants, an all-knowing group well equipped to provide answers on virtually everything known to man, to turn to. And as I am a member of this priesthood, you should consider everything I say in this blog as absolute gospel.
All Encompassing Technologies
From my high perch, I can tell you that digital technologies will touch each and every one of us, in rural and urban communities alike, and that the very nature of work is changing as a result.
It is also true that those communities that offer a goodly dose of STEM education will better equip their young people for a digital future with jobs that you will never fully grasp because of fast-changing technology.
(Mind you, I know the jobs of the future, because I am a consultant. If you pay me and are nice, I will reveal these secrets of unknown to you.)
Because of the technical skills that are and will be needed, more and more companies look for a solid STEM foundation — science, technology, engineering and mathematics — when considering places for future operations.
From a company’s point of view, this only makes sense because it is looking for a future pipeline of talent, which is smart if they have listened to me, the consultant.
As an adviser to both industry and economic development organizations, I’m casting a critical eye at education on a local level, and I am also looking for a tradition of certain kind of work within a community, knowing full well those traditions can and do die over time.
If I am working with a manufacturer on a site selection project, a place that has a deep manufacturing tradition and where schools provide for a robust STEM and vocational training will likely catch my eye.
To the company, I might say, “the people that you want are here in sufficient numbers” or “the people that you want are not here in sufficient numbers.”
Tradition, STEM, vocational training, these are all good things, even in a digital future in which artificial intelligence will reign.
A Touring Texan in New England
I am writing this blog from a hotel room in New England, the birthplace for manufacturing in America. Textiles, machinery, shoes, and guns were all made here and were once thriving industries.
In 1850, New England was the most industrialized part of the United States, accounting for well over a quarter of all manufacturing value in the country and over a third of its industrial workforce. Not surprisingly, it was (and still largely is) the most literate and most educated region in the country.
My wife and I have been touring New England as tourists for the past week and will continue our sojourns for another week. By the time we head home to Dallas, we will have spent time in all six states – Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island and Vermont.
I was least impressed with the city of my birth, which sits in the Connecticut River Valley, the crucible for industrial innovation, pioneering such advances as interchangeable parts and the assembly line, things which influenced manufacturing the world over.
And while I came into this world in this old factory town, which I have absolutely no memories of as an infant member of a vagabond family, I hope to go out in a more scenic place, devoid of urban blight.
A Place of Beauty and History
As I am easily impressed by the visual and history, I found New England a fascinating region. The rocky coast of Maine, the White Mountains in New Hampshire, the Green Mountains in Vermont, simply gorgeous.
Certainly there is a certain allure to the seaports, villages, towns and cities of New England, where it is not uncommon to see a church dating back to 1811 or a general store that dates back to 1831.
Yesterday, I saw a house in Connecticut dating back to 1654. Now how cool is that?
The factory economy, which created great wealth in communities (just look at the houses), is mosty gone now, starting with the loss of textiles in the 1930s.
Still Wealthy After All These Years
But New England remains a very vibrant region, with high technology manufacturers making jet engines, nuclear submarines, pharmaceuticals, robotics, scientific instruments, and medical devices.
I believe this is so because public education remains revered here. Consequently, they grow them up smart, and many of this educated lot get wealthy, too, as Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, have among the highest household income levels in the country.
In Manchester, Vermont, a beautiful small town in Vermont and a tourist destination for the upper crust from New York and Connecticut, I walked into a shop, which billed itself as “purveyors of fine guns,” and saw ornate over-and-under shotguns for sale for $85,000. One was being sold for $99,000.
But certainly some people and some communities in the region have found themselves trailing behind. Western Massachusetts is a very different place from the greater Boston area, where 80 percent of Massachusetts’s citizens live.
Boston and its surrounding area truly is the big dog of New England, accounting for nearly a third of the region’s population and a half of its gross domestic product.
Maine, comprising almost half of the land mass in New England, has less than 10 percent of the population and in some Maine counties where I drove, the poverty was evident.
A Rough Cob Refined
I have been quoting Clemens in this blog partly because he was so spot on in pointing out the absurdities of life and partly because I toured his home in Hartford, Conn., a few days ago.
One of his quips has stuck with me on this particular trip, that “travel is fatal to prejudice.”
I know this to be absolutely true, because in the South, where I have spent most of my life, a “Yankee” is typically viewed as an inferior person from a northern state. Certainly not one to be trusted.
But I do not subscribe to such malignant thoughts, because travel has enlightened me. I know firsthand of “Yankee ingenuity,” kindness, generosity, intelligence and humor.
Good people, even if none of their universities will ever hold a candle to University of Alabama football.
Indeed, if I were a better and more refined person, I might even consider living among them if they would only have me.
But I will not try the patience of anyone in attempting to be something that I am not, which is why Texas suits the rough cob in me just fine.
I’ll see you down the road.
Dean Barber is the president/CEO of Barber Business Advisors, LLC, a location advisory and economic development consulting firm based in Dallas. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org or at 972-890-3733. Mr. Barber is available as a keynote speaker.